There seems to be fairly poor tracking by any formal standards once a product is approved as a food additive. Despite supposedly tracking adverse reactions, the reality has been different at the FDA. Aspartame is a case in point. Apparent collusion, distorted research reports, lack of funding for independent research, questionable practices in tracking adverse reactions and reporting them. It's a pretty ugly sounding story. It's been said that Aspartame is a contract on humanity. Here's one source you might find puts you off Aspartame for good: http://www.holisticmed.com/aspartame/suffer.faq - "Reported Aspartame Toxicity Effects".
Are the estimates (in the report above) of the real number of toxic reactions accurate? I'm no epidemiologist but what struck me was the large number of serious toxic reactions reported by pilots. My conclusion -- I won't use the stuff. And there are suggestions that the offshoot - Neotame - may be even worse.
Everyone pretty much knows the kinds of problems that have been reported with cyclamates and Saccharin. Weirdly - perhaps bad tracking? - the actual dangers still seem unclear after many years of use. However, as I read it, they seem to be substantially less toxic than some more recent artificial sweeteners.
Splenda is the latest and greatest. Reportedly manufactured from sugar by substituting 3 chlorine atoms for 3 hydroxyl groups, some claim that the end product is not what it should be. Apparently if it were made from sugar then when you dissolve it in water (hydrolyze), it ought to produce chlorinated glucose which is a known toxin. Instead it produces chlorinated monosaccharides.
Splenda, or sucralose, is a chlorocarbon. Chlorocarbons have an illustrious history, being known for causing organ, reproductive and genetic damage. Whether sucralose (Splenda) is as safe as the manufacturer claims (which is pretty much what manufacturers always claim) remains to be seen. Here is another reference worth taking a look at: http://www.mercola.com/2000/dec/3/sucralose_dangers.htm - "Secret Dangers of Splenda".
Andrew Weil, MD has some pertinent - and more moderate comments on Aspartame and Splenda here: http://www.drweil.com/u/QA/QA106654/ - "Aspartame: Can a Little Bit Hurt". He suggests using the "precautionary" principle - which basically says if there are questions about the safety of a product, don't use it.
At this point, I think it's my head that's spinning. I'm uncertain whether Splenda is safe, reasonably safe, slightly risky or seriously risky. When I looked at the manufacturer's site and a couple other sites that were all enthused about Splenda, I didn't see any answers to the points the critics are making. Mostly it's all lightness, sweetness and the miracle of modern science.
Like you I've seen some miracles of modern science turn into nightmares when the testing wasn't adequate, when the results were fudged, when coverups went on. So questions exist about all the artificial sweeteners. Splenda may be less dangerous than Aspartame (which I sure wouldn't recommend to anyone). Long-term and independent studies are lacking. And here's the real kicker:
***** From Consumers' Research Magazine "There is no clear-cut evidence that sugar substitutes are useful in weight reduction. On the contrary, there is some evidence that these substances may stimulate appetite."
Now that just tears it. Risk your health using one of these chemicals and then end up eating more because it stimulates your appetite. Terrific.
So what alternatives are there? Surprisingly there are quite a few. One interesting alternative is a South American plant called Stevia. Apparently once considered a potential threat to the sugar industry, it seems to have been deep-sixed early in the twentieth century. It has been used as a sweetener for centuries by South American natives. In the U.S., it seems (somehow) to have been kept from being available as an "additive" and the FDA has said not enough studies have been done. Yet it's widely used by diabetics and in countries such as Japan and Brazil. Stevia is available at health stores as a supplement (though without any indication that it could be used as a sweetener). It's a fascinating story which you can read here: http://www.stevia.net/ - The Stevia Story
More information on alternative sweeteners is in our article: http://www.carb.werkz.org/healthier-sweeteners.php - "Healthier Alternatives to Artificial Sweeteners."
Our health is challenged on all sides these days. New chemicals, new additives, genetically engineered foods, highly processed foods, empty calories, stress and pollution all pose threats to our bodies. I've come to the conclusion that the fewer highly processed, chemically enhanced, questionably assessed, factory created products we ingest, the better off we will probably be.
Our bodies evolved as a part of the natural world and though we are changing the world radically (which is only natural, it is what people do after all), our bodies do not evolve and adapt at the rate technology changes. And for scientific, political and economic reasons, the quality and thoroughness of evaluations done on newly created products don't match up to our industrial creativity.
Finally, balancing the need to lose weight (or maintain an optimum weight) against potential risks creates difficult choices. It's up to you to make the best choice you can for your specific situation -- just remember, that old saw still holds - Let the buyer beware.
Copyright 2005 Richard Keir
http://www.carb.werkz.org is an informational site providing recipes, articles, news and diet resources. Since many recipes are designed to use Splenda, please take a look at http://www.carb.werkz.org and http://www.carb.werkz.org for additional information.
car service from Midway Burlington .. Lockport Chicago limo O’HareCan the colors on your plate tell you what health... Read More
Cholesterol. What images come to mind when you see this... Read More
This is usually the forgotten element of most mass programs.... Read More
Headlines:Nearly a quarter of American adults just got diagnosed with... Read More
THE RISKNo doubt you've heard of the increasingly popular "raw... Read More
You can trust me that I make sure to take... Read More
High blood pressure (hypertension) is a dangerous condition that can... Read More
Nutrition facts have become a part of everyday life because... Read More
Manganese is a metallic mineral that was discovered by a... Read More
It is amazing to be able to say I am... Read More
As a low carb dieter, your diet is undoubtedly high... Read More
A lot of people I've talked with about health supplements... Read More
Post nasal drip is a sensation of mucous build up... Read More
I turned into my parents' driveway in Maryland and parked... Read More
THE RISKWhen you consume food that's high in acid or... Read More
Here is a continuation of the light and darkness metaphor:... Read More
Are you concerned about taking care of your body before... Read More
Since the beginning of time, everyday fruits have been known... Read More
What is Cholesterol?Before we go into how to reduce your... Read More
I am sure you have heard you have to build... Read More
Since the 1930's the western diet has dramatically changed. This... Read More
While oxygen is the key to human survival, it is... Read More
Acid Reflux Disease, or GERD, is a common disease which... Read More
Approximately 30 years ago, food manufacturers were competing against the... Read More
Enzymes are the workers in our body that make everything... Read More
Granger limo Chicago ..With all the news about Splenda of late and the... Read More
The cry of "I have no willpower!" often emerges from... Read More
The reason I remember the first time I was served... Read More
1. Enjoy what you eatWhether someone is following the Atkins... Read More
Because I believe diet and exercise are so important, I'm... Read More
An American culture that is marked by a chronic lack... Read More
Secretly we all want just a few things in life,... Read More
Do you need omega 3 fatty acid in your diet?... Read More
The factors that affect the nutritional requirements of an individual... Read More
Originally, all foods were "organic" ? grown and prepared without... Read More
About 12.6 million Americans currently have heart disease.1.1 million Americans... Read More
The word 'homeostasis' is made up of two Greek words:... Read More
People want to get the very best they can when... Read More
Finding simple ways to reduce my waistline is always a... Read More
It is a question we must ask ourselves continually if... Read More
High Fructose Corn SyrupBefore we get to high fructose corn... Read More
Post nasal drip is a sensation of mucous build up... Read More
Dieters who dejectedly complain they are figuratively "stuck" with their... Read More
What is the Atkins diet and how can it help... Read More
I read a lot about the topics of health and... Read More
Fire ElementAccording to Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) there are five... Read More
One of the most common questions I am asked is... Read More
Strict "no carb" phases of low carb diets have developed... Read More
The nutritional support in critically ill patients can be explained... Read More
Much controversy and argument surrounds the idea that food may... Read More
Nutrition |